Sunday, January 17, 2010

Mike Mayo Testimony On the Banking Crisis

CLSA Analyst and Managing Director Michael Mayo gives a brilliant 10 minute presentation to Congress on the root causes of the banking crises. He pulls no punches and takes on all sides.

The industry was "on steroids" with consumers, government and regulators all guilty. His list of 10 issues, with root causes going back at least 10 years:
1) Excessive Loan Growth (more than 2x GDP)
2) Higher yielding assets (too good to be true?)
3) Too many eggs in one basket (real estate)
4) High balance sheet leverage (10x to 40x over the last 20 years)
5) Risky exotic banking products (like a bad Sangria - you don't know what's in it even after the hangover)
6) Consumers went along (false illusion or prosperity leading to risky borrowing)
7) Accounting changes that allowed reserves to fall (1.8% to 1.2%)
8) Regulators allowing FDIC deposit insurance without premium payments (like paying your life insurance only after you die)
9) Government facilitated allocation of capital to risky borrowers (Fannie and Freddie anyone?)
10) Incentives (compensation is consistent with revenue but not with risk)

At the end Mr. Mayo commented that the crisis was primarily one of not enough capitalism, correctly regulated. Hear Hear. While liquidity must be preserved, bad choices must be met with the consequences - i.e. companies must be allowed to fail.

Even if you disagree with what he said, you have to respect the presentation. Beyond that, you have to respect the decade of research Mr. Mayo has presented. There is a reason he is ranked #1 in his field.

Sure Pat Robinson is wrong - but the FT is just lazy

The FT article is just lazy. Others have highlighted that Pat Robertson is both wrong on history and on what the Bible says about God's will on earth. But the FT reporter failed to check that at the very same time Pat Robertson was also appealing for donations for Haiti.

As for Rush Limbaugh - just check his website and transcript for the full context. At no time did he say not to donate to Haiti. Indeed, other of Rush's comments were about how if the US takes away the tax deduction for charitable donations the ability of American's to contribute will be diminished.

As for the basket case that is Haiti? Predictably there are those who will try to blame everything but the real issues (e.g. Bush, capitalism, the UN, the US generally. . .and even the failure of the Copenhagen climate summit).

The main problem is corruption. Haiti remains one of the most corrupt countries in the world.

Should wealthy nations help? Yes. Should the US do what it can to get aid to those who need it? Of course.

Should the US right be blamed for trying to block such assistance? Of course not. At least not based on the facts of what conservative opinion leaders are actually saying and doing.

Saturday, January 9, 2010

Latest US Unemployment - Not Good

Ed Morrissey at HotAir has the details (linked to title), but bottom line is that US employment picture is not improving and even the AP finally has to admit it. The 10% rate is only part of the picture. Hundreds of thousands are taking themselves out of the work force. The actual number of jobs has dropped by 10 million in the last year. The average time out of work is now 29 weeks. That's more than 6 months. And that's the AVERAGE. How long can you go with no income?

Here's even worse news: The only job growth has been in government and to a lesser extent healthcare. That means the private sector, the true engine of growth, is NOT improving.

That's just the data - now to assign blame: Democrats in US government and ANYONE who supported them in any election in at least the last 3 years. Why? With control of Congress for the last 3 years, and now the White House and a filibuster proof majority in the Senate, the political buck stops there.

To recap the failed policies and policy direction:
1) Community Reinvestment Act and failure to reign in Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac policies: These lead to irresponsible lending practices, translated as lending to people, for political reasons, who are unlikely to repay. This is the true root cause of the sum-prime debacle.
2) Stimulus package that was politically driven (pork) not economically driven (get money in the economy quickly)
3) Failure to consider further tax cuts: Even worse, taxes will increase soon as the AMT has not be re-adjusted, the Bush tax cuts will expire, and as various US States scramble for revenue to stay afloat.
4) Flawed health care "reform" program and opaque political process: The key issue here is that the broad private sector has no choice but to assume this will raise both costs and taxes. This results in a "hunker-down" mentality, meaning no hiring.
5) Take overs instead of letting markets run: Case in point GM. For a good counter-example, Ford is doing much better.
6) Failure to take the War on Terror seriously (and yes that's what it is): Why is this important? It goes to whether the private sector and Americans generally view government as competent. Without a sense that things are going in the right direction, consumers are less likely to open their wallets and private sector employers are again less likely to hire.
7) Focus on Climate Change: Guess what? The vast majority do not believe this is a priority issue, and certainly do not think that the act of breathing (by which I mean expelling CO2 into the air) cause it. Again, Failure of government to focus on economic fundamentals is a root cause of the problem.

To put an Asia view on this, the total number of jobs lost in the US since January is nearly the total population of Hong Kong and Singapore combined! As for the rest of Asia, China is growing at 8%, India nearly as much. Again, those governments are moving as quickly as they can to far more free market and transparent approaches as possible. Even China, with all its command and control mindset at least had a stimulus program that put money into the economy quickly!

Now as for all you who voted for Democrats. WHAT WERE YOU THINKING? Did you honestly believe the people you voted for have policies that are good for the economy? Do you still think that? What facts do you base those views on? I'm not saying you have to believe Republicans or anyone else for that matter. But please. Free markets, lower taxes, smaller government, less (but balanced) regulation, works every time. It'll also keep the government out of your bedroom, your church, and other things you deserve the right to control yourself.

Don't tread on me.







Saturday, January 2, 2010

Happy 2010 (?)

So it remains to be seen whether 2010 will be better than 2009. This will depend a lot on how you define "better". But let's start with our economic stats:

Item                Jan07  4Oct08 31Dec08 31Jul09  31Dec09
Unemployment        4.5%    6.1%   6.7%    9.5%     10.0%
CPI (with energy)   2.0%    5.5%   -1.7%   0.7%     1.8%
Gasoline cost/gal.  $2.25   $3.60  $1.66   $2.60    $2.61
Dow Jones           12,500  10,325 8,776   9,171    10,365
S&P500              1,450   1,099  903     987      1,110
Nasdaq              2,500   1,947  1,577   1,978    1,858

The only bright spot is that the equity markets are back to where they were in October 2008. If you had the stomach for it, and the cash on hand, you could have done quite will from the lows last March with many US markets having their best run since the 30s. You'd have done even better if you put your money in the Hong Kong Hang Seng index, which is up over 80% this year (and has no currency risk vs. the USD by the way). You'd have done even better if you held on to Credit Suisse stock (a former employer of mine), which is up over 100%!

But that doesn't help if you are unemployed. Jobless recovery anyone? Some 21.2M Americans were out of work at some point during 2009. There are also indications that a lot of job seekers simply gave up and are not in the statistics.

So what happened to all that stimulus, cash for clunkers, etc.? TARP arguably had a positive impact on liquidity that is essential for the banking system. Keynesian stimulus, however, did what it always does, which is hardly anything. First of all, it was badly executed: most of the money is not yet in the economy! Second, the initiatives that did proceed created nothing sustainable. Cash for clunkers was a blip. Bailouts of GM have done nothing except line union wallets and generate more requests for money (another $3.9B just this week).

What should have been done? How about immediate tax breaks or deferrals to get the money directly into the hands of consumers, who will first pay down debt, and then start shopping a bit. I'd even go so far as to suggest that activity would generate new tax revenue - at least more than is being generated now!

So what hope for 2010? The economy will no doubt pick up a bit, but I don't see anyone suggesting it will roar back. If anything there is a bit of a bubble in the stock market. Certainly trends towards higher taxes don't help, which brings me to the health care debacle.

How can anyone believe that the health care legislation in congress now will help anything? By all accounts (and it is hard to know exactly what is in these bills) ObamaCare will reduce quality, increase costs, and most certainly raise taxes. How does this help anyone? It drives the cynical view that it isn't about health care, but rather increasing government power over individual choice. For that reason it must be stopped.

At least ClimateGate, defined as the willful falsification of climate data and coordinated suppression of contradictory research by "scientists" with a political agenda in favor of anthropogenic climate change, has slowed down the rush to crush the global economy with bad economics. Even if we agree that climate is changing, the best way to deal with it is not massive wealth transfers controlled by bureaucrats at trans-national agencies. The only tried, true and tested method of adapting to change on a massive scale is the power of free markets, free trade supported by property rights and rule of law. If we had more of that in Zimbabwe, Venezuela, North Korea, most of the rest of the mid-east and Africa - there wouldn't be any problem. China and India get this, as evidenced by their actions at Copenhagen.

By the way, China's economy is growing at about 8%. The stimulus implemented there actually seems to work, but most of the activity is driven by trade and entrepreneurship. Ditto India!

And how about Obama's performance? Well certainly no better than my last post. Most would say worse (just look at the polls). And why not. Obama is the least qualified US president of my lifetime. Even Carter had been a state governor and had military experience. It's not even clear that Obama is that smart. After all, has anyone seen his college grades? Are his books any better than say Palin's (and any less ghostwritten)? B+ isn't even close. D- is more like it, even by the criteria set by the left wing of his own party (Gitmo anyone?) - as for the things that matter to most Americans like jobs, security, and how about choice in health care - well again the polls speak for themselves.

As for foreign policy - the US is now officially a laughing stock. Nobody takes the US seriously. Obama is not seen as credible nor consistent. This leads to perceptions of weakness. At best Obama can be ignored. Worse, the US can be sidelined from the discussion. Is there really anything more to say other than where is Hillary?

At least Iraq is a win! Bummer Afghanistan though. At least the dithering on that decision is over.

So what's this all mean for 2010? Probably not a Republican sweep in Congress. . .but it doesn't create cause for optimism. Best I can wish everyone is that personally things go well and that the undy-bombers are not on your flight. So happy 2010, such as you can!

Sunday, August 2, 2009

So Where Are We After 7 Months?

It's been a while since my January 1 update. So where are we now? 

Item Jan 2007 4 Oct 2008 31 Dec 2008 31 July 2009
Unemployment 4.5% 6.1% 6.7% 9.5%
CPI (with energy) 2.0% 5.5% -1.7% 0.7%
Gasoline cost/gal. $2.25 $3.60 $1.66 $2.60
Dow Jones 12,500 10,325 8,776 9,171
S&P 500 1,450 1,099 903 987
Nasdaq 2,500 1,947 1,577 1,978

I suggested Jan 1 that 2009 would not be worse than 2008. So far, it is a decidedly mixed bag. Markets are up, but that can be expected when stocks are oversold and market players cautiously step back in. Markets are still highly volatile and not for the faint of heart. One view is that the markets are up precisely because of dwindling support in congress for the excesses of Health Care and Environmental legislation. Certainly such factors are bullish. Here's one take: See the July 23rd post.

It also has to be said that the TARP program and related Fed intervention in the markets in November last year did in fact easy the liquidity crisis. Large banks are still under pressure but now not likely to go under and bring the whole system crashing down. Equally, not all firms are too big to fail. CIT for example. 

As for the rest of the economy, things are definitely worse. Unemployment is not improving, and likely will not for most of the year. Clearly the stimulus is not working in terms of job creation. No surprise there really, as the $787B stimulus program is too slow at getting money into the real economy. Politically-driven pork does not make for good economic policy and we are seeing the results. But wait for the spin. Be skeptical of phrases like "GDP growth slower than expected" or "unemployment increases less than forecast." Any reporting based on the rate of change is simply hiding the facts that are actually "GDP continues to contract" and "unemployment continues to increase." 

As an interesting counterpoint, China also embarked on an economic stimulus program. As difficult as it is to know that China economic data is accurate, the results would seem to show that China's economy is back on track. The difference? China got most of the cash into the economy quickly and took on far less debt. Yes, the Chinese Communists are in a position to lecture the US on how to do this! 

So how's Obama doing? Sure Obama seems pretty smart alright, but more in a smart-alecky I-know-alot kind of way. The real issue is inexperience. He has never had any real executive experience and it is starting to show. Even worse, he seems to be governing far to the left of his campaign implied.

Where to begin:

1) Economy itself: See above, and:

-GM and Chrysler bailouts - should have let them fail even before being inaugurated. The sop to unions and strong-arming of secured creditors will result in further damage to those firms. Want to invest? don't trust any firm with large unions. Want a car? buy a Ford. Even Cash for Clunkers, being touted in the press as a success, takes perfectly good cars off the road and perfectly good car parts off the market. This will kill a lot of skilled jobs around the country (think of your local car repair guy). 
-Tax increases on the "rich" - the top 1% of taxpayers, less than 1.4M people, pay 40% of US federal income tax. In some states, and with other taxes included the marginal rate will potentially exceed 57%. What do rich people do when faced with high taxes? They either move, make less money, or find ways to make money that doesn't incur such high tax. What happens then? Either more deficits or higher taxes for everyone else. Neither approach increases economic growth.

-Cap and Trade - despite what you might hear, this is not a market mechanism for managing CO2 output. It is just another tax that will hit everyone's energy bill. Whether or not CO2 (or any other human activity) leads to Climate Change is beside the point. Cap and Trade and any other market that cannot be benchmarked against something real that people actually want cannot work. India and China get this and are not going to subject their economies to such economic silliness. 

By the way, profits are good: it is after all, how we pay for all this. Without it there are no jobs, taxes, investors to buy debt. 

2) Which brings me to Health Care. First of all, this is a big topic, 17% of the US economy, and something that should not be rushed. Any significant national level reform will not be sustainable without broad-based political support of all Americans. The latest polls have significant majorities of Americans opposing the changes being proposed in Congress. Why is that? Short answer: THERE IS NO HEALTH CARE CRISES IN AMERICA! 

Here is a good summary of what is right with US health care. Americans have better survival rates across broad categories of common diseases, shorter waiting times, better access to preventative tests, and overwhelmingly better access to medical innovation. The vast majority of new medical treatments and technologies originate in the US, thanks largely to private industry. As for the 45 million uninsured? About 1/3 can be covered by existing government programs. Another 1/3 simply choose not to get coverage - many of those are indeed wealthy and can pay for any contingency on their own. As for the remaining 1/3? Well assuming they are a legally in the USA then why can't existing programs be extended to help this group? 

So what is it exactly that the omnibus legislation making its way through Congress, which few have read and even fewer understand, supposed to achieve? I'd say that the burden of proof is for Congress and Obama to prove that one of the greatest health-care systems in the history of humanity is not made worse. Has anybody heard of "At first do no harm"? Perhaps someone should read Obama the Hippocratic oath. 

And what about a few other items that would actually reduce costs but are never discussed? 

-Legal Costs: Malpractice insurance, litigation, and tests that aren't medically necessary but given to address the other two are a significant cost burden. How about looking at that? And it's not just that. To share a personal experience, I worked on a project for a Big Pharma recently. The project involved securely moving data as part of shutting down some research labs and centralizing in fewer facilities. This project globally cost $50M just to move data securely that might be needed one day for future regulatory compliance or litigation. Without that overhead the whole thing could have probably been done for $5M. All those costs add up - oh and don't forget the more than 250 lawyers in the company's head office. It's not about Marketing vs. Research. It's about the cost of compliance and litigation vs. delivering life-saving treatments to patients. 

-Intellectual Property rights for drugs and therapies and/or streamlined approvals: It takes about 10 years for a drug to be approved. That leaves only about 7 years of patent rights for the inventor to recoup the investment. That leads to lots of good therapies never seeing the light of day. Generics might be cheaper, but a drug with a longer profitable life for its inventors would be cheaper too, and we'd have more of them. 

-Not enough free market sense: I've written before how hard it is to pay cash at a clinic. A good counterexample is Lasik, which by the way has also come down dramatically in cost with safety simultaneously improving. Why? Because Lasik follows free-market principles. Most clinics do not. 

So how about those last 1/3 uninsured again - about 15M people. Here's a modest proposal: Pay them all $1000/year in insurance each. That's $15B/year, or $150B over 10 years. That's a lot less than what's in front of Congress now and doesn't destroy the system for the rest of us. 

3) So how about Foreign Policy? Are US interests in the world being advanced? Is the US a leader in world institutions? Are we loved by all that hated us because of Bush? At best you'd have to say things are off to a rocky start. In the part of the world where I live, the US is basically ignored. China seems to have worked out that there is nothing the US can really say or do that is of any long term consequence, and certainly not under the Obama administration (see above under China lecturing the US on economics). Russia? same story. North Korea - well not making much progress there are we. Iran? Let's see how long it takes before they test a nuclear weapon. Europe? Seems to be moving to the right of Obama on a number of issues. Hmm wonder why. Could Europe be right? 

4) Supreme Court Nomimation: Actually this one doesn't look so bad. Don't get me wrong, I'm unlikely to agree with Justice Sotomayor on a number of political issues. Nevertheless, she does seem to be a competent jurist with a proven track record that is available for review, and for the most part (90% of the time) has passed Supreme Court scrutiny when tested there. Is she the best possible candidate for the highest court in the land? Probably not. Is Obama within his rights to nominate here? Most certainly. Should she be confirmed by the Senate? In the absence of any good reason not to, I'd have to say yes. In other words the burden of proof is on the Senate to say no, and nothing of consequence has come up to suggest that confirmation is not warranted. . .and in any case, she's probably not going to be any worse or any better than Justice Souter. 

So what's left? How about Beer Diplomacy. Actually I like this one. Of course it was politically inept for Obama to wade into the Gates/Crowley affair without at least having all the facts. Presidents probably shouldn't get into such local matters at all. But it is a time honored tradition for men of goodwill to gather around a table with a few cold ones to hash out difference, agree to disagree if that's the situation, and then move on. I'll raise a glass to that. 

So let's end on that note: How about it Mr. President? More Beer Summits and less destroying that which makes America great. It might save your presidency. And we know it's more about you than it is about the rest of us, so what's not to like in that? 

Sunday, April 19, 2009

Tokyo Cherry Blossoms

No politics today. Just a few pictures from a recent trip to Tokyo.

Cherry Blossoms near the Imperial Palace. 

Followed by some sakura-tinged shochu! 

And a flower arrangement at the Palace hotel. 

But what's this with JPY 200 drinks! That's US$2 for a full beer. Deflation in Japan again? I'll take it while it lasts! 



Thursday, January 1, 2009

Happy New Year - And a 2008 Round-Up

It's the last day of 2008 and time for a round up of the last 12 months. I started this blog just about a year ago, and it has certainly been an interesting year! Where to begin? How about a look back at some posts from the year:

It was an election year, and a number of posts hit on that theme. Way back in February I posted that Clinton fatigue would probably give Obama an edge. That certainly happened! However, by April I thought Obama was done, and even in August I thought Obama might not make it. Got that wrong! 

An Even bigger mistake in that same August post was that I thought the worst of the recession was over. Even more wrong there! But I did get it right back in April that Citi was not out of the woods yet. 

What else? Well it seems the US has won in Iraq. The drop in commodity prices has seriously impacted Chavez, Russia, and Iran's ability to export revolution backed by petrodollars. Global Warming (or if you prefer Climate Change) has not ended life as we know it. 

But here's the most interesting thing I hadn't anticipated: Obama is the new Bush! Liberals are still trying to blame Bush, and by extension all Republicans, for all the ills of the world. However, the Obama foreign policy and economic teams look a lot like Clinton 2 with a bit of Bush (e.g. Sec. Def. Gates) thrown in. Obama has already back-pedaled on Iraq troop withdrawal plans, and on closing down Gitmo, and on Patriot act wiretaps. Obama has deferred on raising taxes and the stimulus packages between Bush and Obama are, well about the same. He didn't even support Gay Marriage (well at least not forcefully) in California. This puts the hard left in a bit of a logical bind. If Obama is right on these points, then Bush was not wrong. If Bush was wrong, then Obama is now wrong, and the better vote would have been for McCain! Go figure! 

Now how about the Bernie Madoff! $50B gone! How so many fell for this is almost unimaginable. But the red flag for me is simply this: You don't put your money with an individual, or even a company he controls. If you want to invest in a hedge fund, you put it with a custodian who can independently verify trades. This is pretty basic. How so many people got it wrong just goes back to the old adage: if it is too good to be true it probably is! 

So where are we  on the economic status for January 2007 vs. Oct 4, 2008 vs. today? 
Item Jan 2007 4 Oct 2008 Today (31 Dec 2008)
Unemployment 4.5% 6.1% 6.7%
CPI (with energy) 2.0% 5.5% -1.7% (latest)
Gasoline cost/gal. $2.25 $3.60 $1.66
Dow Jones 12,500 10,325 8,776
S&P 500 1,450 1,099 903
Nasdaq 2,500 1,947 1,577

So energy and commodity prices came down a lot. Deflation isn't good, but this correction probably is because it pumps billions of dollars of purchasing power back into the economy. That will help consumers weather the reduction in credit, and will do more than any stimulus package ever could. Which raises the question, why do we need a stimulus package again? If any such "pump-priming" is needed, how about a further tax cut. . .oh I forgot, politicians can't make pork out of a tax cut, well at least not as easily!

Will 2009 be worse than 2008? I'll go out on a limb and say no it won't. Here are my reasons:
1) As core commodity prices drop, especially energy, suddenly a lot of unprofitable businesses become profitable again. For example, airlines. 
2) As much as the main-stream press wanted a recession on Bush's watch, the press is not going to let Obama and a Democratic congress suffer the same fate. There will be more economic cheerleading the minute there is any good news that can somehow be linked to an Obama policy (whether true or not). 
3) Obama's economic team isn't going to be as radical as some (including I) fear, and the Republican filibuster capability in the Senate as well as public disdain for bailouts, will throttle back some of what could have been excesses. 
4) Things weren't actually that bad - even jobless claims slumped much more than expected - 492,000 new unemployment claims last month vs. 586,000 the month before. 
5) If so many think things will be bad in 2009, then chances are the opposite will happen. 

Will things be dicey? Sure. I'm not jumping in to buy stocks now. But soon there will be many buying opportunities. It could still go all pear-shaped, if for example Obama and Congress raise taxes, or print money to bailout UAW fat-cats. But here's hoping Obama actually wants a 2nd term. If he doesn't blow it, he might actually get that!

Well there you have it. I'll be back in Hong Kong next week, and will provide updates from the Far East when I'm back. In the meantime, Happy New Year's everyone!